Are you starting to think about candy alternatives for Halloween? Keep scrolling to get my top picks for non-candy Halloween treats to give trick-or-treaters this year!
This list of non-candy Halloween treats to give trick or treaters was originally published September 21, 2021 and was updated September 3, 2022 and contains affiliate links which means if you purchase something from one of my affiliate links, I may earn a small commission that goes back into maintaining this blog.
Do you want to give out something other than candy this Halloween?
We have some great ideas that will make your little ones smile. They are sure to love these treats and it’s a great way to avoid any allergies or issues with candy.
You can also rest easy knowing they won’t be eating too much sugar!
These options are available in large quantities, so you don’t need to worry about running out of items before the night is over. It’s all-inclusive and there is something for everyone!
There is no better feeling than giving back without sacrificing quality or quantity. You can even get creative by making up little party bags filled with whatever goodies you choose!
The best part? Your kids will love these items just as much as traditional candy, if not more!
We promise they won’t complain about not getting more Tootsie Rolls or Jolly Ranchers. And they won’t want to trade these items with their friends.
This way, every kid gets what they want and everyone wins at Halloween! A win-win situation indeed…and who doesn’t like those?!
Keep scrolling to check out our selection of non-candy alternatives perfect for trick-or-treaters on Halloween night!
What is the Teal Pumpkin Project?
Have you noticed that more and more kids are diagnosed with food allergies each year?
The Teal Pumpkin Project is a worldwide movement to make Halloween safer for everyone. Teal pumpkins on your doorstep mean you have non-food treats available, such as glow sticks or small toys!
This simple act promotes inclusivity and makes trick-or-treaters with food allergies feel safe and happy this holiday season.
We’ve been participating for the past 9 years. And it’s really easy. You can either set aside a bowl of non-food items or only offer allergy-friendly items.
You can either paint a real pumpkin teal or just pick up a reusable teal pumpkin that you can bring out year after year (which is what we do).
Best Non-Candy Halloween Treats for 2023
Halloween Coloring Books
These Halloween coloring books are a must-have addition to your party supplies. They can be enjoyed by all ages and have some fun images that will draw kids into the book as they color them in.
There are also 60 of these cool coloring books so you’ll definitely find what you’re looking for with this bulk pack!
Comes in a 60 pack.
Zipper Wristband Bracelets
These Halloween party bracelets are made of high-quality PP, durable and sturdy.
They measure 2.5″ in diameter for the perfect fit on most kids’ wrists so they won’t fall off while your children run around their neighborhood trick or treating this year!
The 7 different patterns include a pumpkin, a skull, a witch, a ghost, a bat, and other very cute and funny designs.
Comes in a 28 pack.
Halloween Stickers for Waterbottles and Electronics
Kids are all about durable stickers that they can put on notebooks, water bottles, devices, etc. There’s a reason why so many teachers give these sturdy stickers out as prizes!
This Halloween sticker set comes with 100 individual stickers that are sure to spread some Halloween cheer.
These Halloween-themed stickers come complete with all your favorite characters from this spooky season: Pickachu, black cats, ghosts, jack-o-lanterns, witches, and vampires… even mummies make an appearance!
You can cut them up for individual stickers or hand out full sheets to trick-or-treaters.
Comes with 100 stickers.
Halloween Wind Up Toys
Wind-up toys are a fun way for kids to play and learn while they wind up their favorite Halloween characters!
These easy-to-grasp, smooth action figures can improve coordination, imagination skills with parents.
You’ll love these adorable Halloween characters such as a vampire, eyeball, pumpkin, skull, mummy, ghost, etc.
All these wind-up toys do different actions like walking around, shaking their head, crawling, and more.
Comes in a pack of 24.
Halloween Bookmark Rulers
These Halloween bookmark rulers are perfect for marking your page in a book or measuring things!
There are 6 different designs available including a mummy, spider, pumpkin, Frankenstein, black cat, and a bat.
They are made of 100% lightweight smooth vinyl, which makes them both durable and flexible.
Comes in a pack of 144.
Mini Mochi Squishy Toys
Grab the Halloween Squishy Toys for kids! There are 12 styles, including bats, ghosts, black cats, pumpkins, witches, spiders, and more. Each style has 2pcs so you get 24 across all variations.
They’re soft and smooth with cute designs to twist stretch squeeze play around. They’ll be dirty after playing with them but just use soap and water to make them clean again.
Comes with 24 to a pack.
Mini Plush Halloween Toys
These Halloween stuffed toys are the perfect decoration for this spooky holiday.
The plush dolls come with seven different designs including a pumpkin, scarecrow, vampire, skeleton, ghost, monster, and witch.
And each doll is equipped with an easy hanging loop to have it decorate anywhere in your kids’ rooms or on their backpacks!
Comes with 28 to a pack.
Light Up Flashing LED Rings
These Halloween rings are great for party favors and decorations. Each pack contains approximately 9-13 different styles, such as pumpkins, ghosts, skulls, bats, pirates, eyeballs, spiders, etc.
They’re made of soft plastic and silicone so they can be adjusted to fit kids of all ages!
You could put them on fingers or in your hair or use them as table lights or wall decorating – the possibilities are endless.
Comes with 50 to a pack.
Create Your Own Stickers Activity
You’ll get 42 sheets of Halloween stickers for kids to create their own pumpkins, mummies, zombies, witches, monsters, and vampires.
These cute Halloween party stickers are colorfully printed on high-quality material that can be used multiple times by gently peeling off each piece from the sheet and sticking on the characters!
There are 6 different character styles with 7 sheets per style.
While they are made specifically for Halloween parties or just everyday use – we’re not here judge!
Comes with 42 sheets.
Silicone Wristband Bracelets
You will receive 40pcs Halloween rubber wristbands to give out as trick-or-treating favors.
This set includes 8 Halloween patterns such as pumpkins, skeletons, “Happy Halloween”,”Trick or Treat”, monsters, eyes, and more!
These bracelets are made from silicone rubber that’s soft but durable which makes them safe for small hands.
Comes with 40.
Punch Balloons
Pumpkins, witches, and ghosts come to life with the Halloween Punch Balloons.
Each Halloween balloon is made of 100% natural latex so they’re fun for kids to play with!
The 7 different colors are bright and vibrant – perfect for any Halloween party or celebration, in addition to trick-or-treat goodies.
Comes with 42 pieces to a pack.
Glowing Temporary Tattoos
Are you looking for fun Halloween party accessories? These luminous temporary tattoos are a good choice!
The super spooky elements in these glow-in-the-dark fake tattoos include zombies, skeletons, vampires, pumpkins, and other Halloween-related patterns.
They’re made of high-quality material that doesn’t smell like chemicals or cause allergies. Very suitable for kids and adults to play together with friends at a spooky-themed gathering!
Comes with 250 styles on 24 sheets.
Glow In The Dark Bouncing Balls
This Halloween bouncing ball set includes 100 pieces of glow-in-the-dark bouncing balls with 20 unique designs. Some of the designs include pumpkins, spiders, gravestones, skulls, black cats, and more.
Expose these balls to light for the best glowing effect because the balls are specially designed to glow brighter under direct lighting.
100 pieces!
Ink Stampers
These little Halloween stampers are a lot of fun for kids.
There are 25 different designs including pumpkins, ghosts, mummies, and more!
Plus they come in 4 spooky Halloween colors: Pumpkin Orange, Evil Black, Witch Purple, and Bloody Vampire Red.
100 pieces in the box.
Slap Bracelets
Prepare for tons of fun with these Halloween slap bracelets! Each bracelet comes with 18 different patterns so you can mix and match to your heart’s desire.
Whether it be at a trunk-or-treat or handing them out as treats, you will have lots of eager young faces smiling up at you.
Comes with 72.
Halloween Candy Alternatives FAQs
If you still want to hand out a food item, there are plenty of options. My neighbor hands out little bags of chips that are always a huge hit. We’ve passed out mini water bottles that were a surprising hit, too. Basically, any pre-packaged items you’d pack in a lunchbox work well for Halloween night.
That really depends on how many trick-or-treaters you usually get. Non-candy options are often a little more expensive, so it can help your budget to give kids the choice.
If you end up being more popular than you expected, you can always look around your home for any other items that might work (like packaged Happy Meal toys or even coins). And you can always turn off the lights and make it clear that you are done for the night.
Allergy-friendly Halloween candies include brands like Enjoy Life, YumEarth, and Free2b, which offer treats free from common allergens like nuts, dairy, and gluten.
It’s generally not recommended to give out homemade Halloween treats to trick-or-treaters, as many parents are cautious about accepting non-commercially packaged foods for safety reasons.
Healthy Halloween treats can include small boxes of raisins, mini packets of pretzels, fruit leather, or even non-food items like stickers, pencils, or small toys.
Halloween Non-Candy Treats Wrap-Up
I hope you enjoyed my top picks for non-candy Halloween treats.
These are healthy alternatives to the traditional sweets that fill your home this time of year, but they’re also perfect for participating in the Teal Pumpkin Project which is a movement to include kids with allergies!
We have tons of other great content related to all things Halloween so be sure and keep checking back as we get closer!